I guess my hair is sinful? and other thoughts while reading Jane Eyre

Jane Eyre. Just the name makes me feel like I’m on a windswept moor straggling toward a looming house in the distance. The moor is bare, except for a gnarled tree where ravens roost… just kidding. It makes me feel like I’m sitting in my literature classroom agonizing over an in-class essay. Turns out, the cold chill of the moor and the cold chill of having two minutes to finish my paper aren’t that different.

Anyway, here are 7 thoughts I had while reading Jane Eyre, that most wonderful and confusing of Gothic novels. WARNING: spoilers ahead!

1. I guess my hair is sinful?

According to Mr. Brocklehurst, it is, because I have naturally curly hair and sometimes wear it in a braid.

“‘Why, in defiance of every precept and principle of this house, does she conform to the world so openly—here in an evangelical, charitable establishment—as to wear her hair one mass of curls?’


‘[E]ach of the young persons before us has a string of hair twisted in plaits which vanity itself might have woven[.]'”

Thanks for the tip, Mr. Brocklehurst! I guess the only way to heaven is to straighten my hair–or better yet, shave my head!

2. Helen is way better than me, and she’s like 12.

She’s the only person who is nice to Jane after Mr. Brocklehurst humiliates her. She forgives people endlessly. She gives a deep and moving speech about the hope of salvation right before she dies–and she’s, what, eleven or twelve? I can only wish to be as cool as her.

3. I am SO glad I live in the 21st century.

Tuberculosis is treatable. You don’t have to travel everywhere by carriage. CPS is a thing. If you’re a woman, your life isn’t over if you’re not married by age 18. So many perks!

4. Jane, you can totally do better than Mr. Rochester.

I know you’ve met like 5 men in your entire life, and they’re all terrible, but Mr. Rochester is terrible too. He’s not nice to you, and he’s not attractive or virtuous or whatever you’re looking for in a man. You, on the other hand, are brave and smart and awesome. Why are you even considering falling in love with him?

5. So many red flags. All the red flags.

Mr. Rochester pretends to date Blanche, who is a total jerk, just to make Jane jealous. Then when he does propose to Jane, he says things like, “I have a terrible secret but I can’t tell you until we’re married.” Jane knows that there’s more to the fire and the screams in the attic than Grace Poole, and she knows that Rochester is hiding it from her. Then, when Jane does find out about Bertha, Rochester tries to persuade her that bigamy is OK. Yet, for some reason, she still loves him? Don’t ignore the red flags, Jane!

6. St. John, you are not God.

This probably comes as a surprise to you, but it’s true. You’d make an even worse husband than Rochester, and that’s saying something. Just because Jane doesn’t want to marry you doesn’t mean she is defying the will of God. You’re first cousins and honorary siblings! Just go to India as a brother/sister pair! I know that in your mind, you either have to hate Jane forever or marry her, but–guess what–you have more options than that. Crazy, I know.

7. OK, Jane, if you’re happy, I guess I’m happy…

I still think that Rochester’s pretty creepy. But now that he’s blind and poor, he seems to have mellowed a little. Jane, you’ve lived through a lot by now, so we want you to be happy. If Rochester is no longer trying to be bigamous, I guess you can marry him.

What did you think of Jane Eyre? Did any of these thoughts cross your mind, too? Let me know in comments!

Featured image source

19 thoughts on “I guess my hair is sinful? and other thoughts while reading Jane Eyre

  1. I don’t why but I have always loved Jane Eyre it such a strange novel
    And like you said there are many creepy things about Mr. Rochester but I can’t help but like it and love them. Have you ever read Jane by April Linder it’s a modern retelling and it is really fabulous. It’s different but it still has the same heart as the original. I wrote a review of it and will be posting it Monday if you are interested.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve never liked Rochester. He lies to Jane and uses her because he believes that her virtue will somehow renew him. But he wants her to live in sin with him to achieve this! Plus he’s constantly condescending about his age and vast experience, pretends to be a gypsy to make Jane talk to him, dates and throws aside another woman to make Jane jealous. And the text suggests that he wants to jump ahead of the wedding night so to speak, but Jane puts him off. He’s not virtuous and Jane really just got lucky that he had a near death experience and reformed at the end. Not sure why she wanted to marry him BEFORE he learned patience and humility.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s